Stop Chasing Cheap Clicks

Rev & Reach from PopSpeed Digital

If the ad report you show your leadership team, or your client, leads with how cheap your clicks are, you’re celebrating the wrong number. Click costs have more than doubled in 10 years, yet cost per lead just dropped for the first time in five.

Lori Jo Vest explains why expensive clicks that turn into customers beat cheap clicks that don’t, what belongs at the top of your ad report, and why clients only care about one question: what did you sell?

Stop chasing cheap clicks.

Themes discussed in this episode:

Episode Highlights

0:09 – Lori opens with the episode’s challenge: if your ad report celebrates cheap clicks, you’re leading with the wrong number.
0:44 – The WordStream benchmarks: average cost per click was $2.32 in 2016 and is $5.42 in the latest report, based on more than 13,000 search campaigns across 23 industries.
1:19 – The twist: average cost per lead across Google and Microsoft Ads went down for the first time in five years, to $66.69. Advertisers are getting more efficient, not finding cheaper auctions.
2:13 – A lesson from arts and entertainment, one of the cheapest categories at a $1.63 median cost per click and 12.75% click-through. Date-night ads drew cheap clicks, but ticket sales didn’t follow.
3:10 – LocaliQ’s warning: obsessing over cost per click can steer you toward cheaper clicks that don’t convert. Watch conversion rate and cost per lead instead.
3:40 – What goes at the top of your ad report: cost per lead or sale, results, conversion rate and revenue per dollar spent. Cost per click goes at the bottom, as a diagnostic.
4:41 – Make sure your conversion tracking counts real actions, like calls, form fills and purchases. Landing on a page doesn’t count.
5:17 – This week’s challenge: open your ad account, sort campaigns by cost per lead instead of cost per click, and see whether your best campaign changes.
5:33 – A side note for small and newer agencies: clients don’t care about engagement or CPM. They care about what you sold.

Top Quotes

  • “Stop chasing cheap clicks.”
  • “Expensive clicks that turn into customers are so far superior to the cheap clicks that don’t.”
  • “Cheap and clickable isn’t the same as profitable.”
  • “Each click costs more, but it takes fewer clicks to get a lead.”
  • “Clients don’t care. What did you sell? That is what your metric is.”

Key Takeaways & Action Items

  • Stop leading with cost per click. A low CPC on its own says nothing about whether your ads are selling.
  • Judge by cost per lead or cost per sale. That’s the number that shows whether your spend is working.
  • Watch conversion rate closely. Raise the share of clicks that convert, even if it means showing your ad to fewer people.
  • Report revenue per dollar spent. Show leadership or clients what each ad dollar brought back.
  • Move cost per click to the bottom of the report. Treat it as a diagnostic for efficiency, not a scorecard.
  • Track real actions. Count calls, form fills and purchases as conversions, not page visits.
  • Take the challenge. Sort your campaigns by cost per lead this week and see whether your top performer changes.

Rev & Reach Episode 32 Transcript
“Why Your Cost Per Click Doesn’t Matter”

Lori Jo Vest

 [0:09] Hello, I’m Lori Jo Vest. Thank you so much for joining me for this episode of Rev and Reach. We’re going to talk about why your cost per click doesn’t matter. Stop chasing cheap clicks. If your ad report that you show your leadership team, or if you’re an agency, what you show your client, leads with how cheap your clicks are, you’re celebrating the absolute wrong number. Expensive clicks that turn into customers are so far superior to the cheap clicks that don’t.
[0:43] So, an entity called WordStream began publishing benchmark data about cost per click and cost per lead back in 2016, when Google Ads cost an average per click of $2.32. And in the latest report, the average Google Ads cost per click is $5.42. Not bad, right? 10 years, doubled. I kind of expect that. And that report is based on over 13,000 search campaigns across 23 industries, and it ran April 2025 through March 2026.
[1:19] Now, here’s the twist on this. Even with clicks costing more, the overall average cost per lead, which is a different measurable, on both Google and Microsoft Ads, went down for the first time in five years. So the average cost per lead across all industries, and let’s say on Google Ads, was $66.69. Now, people read that — people who immerse themselves in data like this all day, every day; that’s not me — they read this as advertisers getting more efficient, not auctions getting cheaper, because they’re not. Each click costs more, but it takes fewer clicks to get a lead, or it should take fewer clicks to get a lead. So the point is, people that are winning right now are paying more per click, and they’re still coming out ahead because they’re getting the end result. They’re getting the conversion, the sales lead, the ticket sale, whatever it is.
[2:15] So one of the segments that we’ve been working in lately is arts and entertainment, and it’s actually one of the cheapest categories when it comes to cost per click, with a median cost of $1.63 and an average 12.75% click-through. Cheap and clickable isn’t the same as profitable. What we noticed when we were doing Google Ads — and we had some pretty tight targeting areas — the headlines were all related to date night, to going out on a Friday or Saturday night, you know, having really great entertainment. And our cost per click was low, and we were getting these great numbers. We weren’t selling that many tickets. So cheap and clickable is not the same as profitable. If tickets or leads aren’t following a low cost per click, you’re still spending your budget. You’re still spending out your budget while you wait to see what converts.
[3:10] There’s another organization called LocaliQ, and they warn that obsessing over cost per click can steer you toward cheaper clicks that don’t convert. Conversion rate and cost per lead are the things you really want to look at. Is an ad converting? What percentage of those clicks is actually converting? Increase that percentage, and you may have to decrease the number of leads coming in, because you want to show that ad to fewer people. So watch conversion rate and cost per lead as your metrics.
[3:43] So if you are doing analytics reporting to your client or to your leadership team, the things that you want to put at the top of the report: cost per lead or cost per sale. How many people came in, you know, how much product was sold. Conversion rate: we got this many clicks and they converted at this percentage. The revenue generated per dollar spent — that’s a really important metric. Cost per click actually goes at the bottom. And you want to look at that more as a diagnostic. It’s not really telling you how well you’re doing as much as giving you a measurable for being more efficient. If you can stick with your targeting, keep the conversion rate high, keep the lead rate high, but bring the cost per click down, then you’re really building efficiency into your campaign. So you still want to track it. You just don’t want to make it top of the report, because it’s not that important.
[4:41] So the end result: basically, you want to check and make sure that conversion tracking counts real actions — calls, form fills, purchases, all that kind of thing. The thing that actually brings in the money to your client’s bank account. And WordStream, again, their report counts any tracked contact as a lead. That could be a call, a chat, a form fill, or an email that they opened or sent to you. So all those things count as conversion. Not just landing on a landing page — that does not count. It needs to convert when it gets there.
[5:17] So I’m going to challenge you today to actually open your ad account and sort your campaigns by cost per lead instead of cost per click, and see whether your best campaign changes. See whether you’re actually measuring what counts.
[5:33] And I’ll add a little side note here for small and newer ad agencies. We’ve been doing this for nine years, coming up in February. And what we’ve learned is the metrics that we talk about in the industry — oh, engagement, and, you know, CPM, and all those kinds of numbers — clients don’t care. What did you sell? That is what your metric is. So when you’re doing your analytics reporting, make sure you’re measuring what counts.
[6:05] So that’s what I’ve got for you today. I’ll be back in a couple of weeks with some helpful, useful information to help you make your digital marketing better, based on what we’ve learned here at PopSpeed Digital Marketing in Birmingham, Michigan. We have a website at revandreach.popspeeddigital.com if you’d like to go there and listen to past episodes. You can also find us on all the podcast channels — Spotify, Apple, all those other channels — and on YouTube. If you are already watching me on YouTube, do me a favor: hit that subscribe button and follow along, because we do aim to share really great information that you can use to get more ROI from your digital marketing. Take care.